It has now been about two weeks since Google launched its Penguin update and so far Google are happy with the new spam fighting algorithm. However some who have been hurt by this update are still wondering how to recover and there still remains a concern about negative SEO. Matt Cutts, who is head of Google’s web spam team, has come out and answered some questions about this algorithm update.

Has Penguin Been a success?

The first question that was asked was ,the goal of any algorithm update is to improve the search results. So how has Penguin been for Google?

To which Matt Cutts replied “It’s been a success from our standpoint”

How About Those Weird Results?

Soon after Penguin was released, people immediately started showing some examples of very weird results. For example the official Viagra website was not listed on search results, however some hacked sites were. Along with this some people also spotted that an empty website was listed in the search results for “make money online”. There were also reports of other empty sites ranking on search engines as well. Scraper sites were also reported outranking the sites that they had scraped.

So the main question after all of this is how can Google Penguin be a success after all of this?

Well Cutts has said that many of these issues existed before Penguin had launched and were not caused by the new spam-fighting algorithm.

Revisiting the Viagra issue mentioned earlier, which has now been fixed, was a problem before Penguin hit. Penguin did not cause this.

False Positives?There are a Few Cases

What about these false positives? The people who feel they have been unfairly hit by Penguin when they weren’t carrying out any spam?

Cutts has come out and said the following about this

“We’ve seen a few cases where we might want to investigate more, but this change hasn’t had the same impact as Panda or Florida”

The Panda Update was Google’s big update which targeted low-quality spam last year. The Florida Update was a major update which Google carried out in 2003 that intended to improve its search quality. I would have to agree that both of these updates impacted sites a lot more than Penguin has, however not everyone may agree with me. It is also worth reminder that for any site which has “lost” in the rankings, someone out there has gained. However you rarely hear from those who have gained. The bottom line is Google seem to be pretty confident that the Penguin Update is indeed catching people who were spamming, just as was intended.


Why is Spam Still Getting Through?

When looking into reports recently spam is definitely the core reason why websites are dropping, but if penguin is working, why are sites that are clearly spamming still getting through?

Cutts answered this question with the following:

“No algorithm is perfect. While we’d like to achieve perfection, our litmus test is, ‘Do things get better than before?”

Cutts also explained that “Penguin was initially designed to be quite precise, to act against pages when there was an extremely high-confidence of spam being involved. The downside to this however is that some spam may get through, but the upside is that you have fewer false positives.”

Recovering from the Penguin Update

One of the most difficult things with this update is advising people on how to recover, this is because they have been deemed of spamming Google.


in the past if you have been caught spamming Google you were told to file a reconsideration request, however Google have come out and specifically said that reconsideration requests will not help those who have been hit by Penguin. Google have said that you will recover naturally if you remove the spam that is on your site. Along with this one of the main reasons that websites have dropped is due to their bad linking practices which Penguin is also targeting. Those People who have used sponsored WordPress themes, poor quality reciprocal linking, have purchased links or may have participated in linking networks, such as those recently targeted by Google may also find themselves being targeted by this Penguin update.

The main question after this then is how can people pull themselves out of these link networks, if they don’t have control over those links now? Matt Cutts answered this question with the following